Who Should the Lions Take in Chivas USA Dispersal Draft?

The official dissolution of Chivas USA and the Dispersal Draft that will follow at some point this off-season serve as sharp reminders of the nature of Major League Soccer. As many a disgruntled soccer purist will point out, MLS is still a single-entity league, where the league office, rather than the teams themselves, has the final say in almost everything that happens off the pitch.

Rather than having all of Chivas’ players simply become free agents, as would be expected in most major soccer leagues or other American professional sports, those on the roster will re-enter the league through what’s called a dispersal draft. The details haven’t been finalized, but it will work just like any other draft for the most part. The teams will be ordered, likely from worst to first, and select the players that they would like off of Chivas USA’s roster.

We do know two things for sure:  according to MLS Executive Vice President Todd Durbin, there will in fact be a dispersal draft this off-season, and Orlando City and NYCFC will take part. What we’re unsure of is where in the order the two expansion clubs will fall, along with any additional rules and minutia. ESPN is reporting that the draft may take place on Dec. 1, but that is unconfirmed.

In the only previous dispersal draft (in 2002, when the Tampa Bay Mutiny and Miami Fusion folded), we also saw two top-10 Superdraft picks traded. If Orlando is given a top pick, but it’s not sold on any of Chivas’ players, they could attempt to add another pick in the Superdraft. Also, there could be the option of trading for allocation money or even an international roster spot.

Personally, I would expect to see Orlando and New York City FC receive the first and second picks in the draft, simply because MLS has a vested interest in their success this year. However, that’s simply conjecture. Here is what Chivas’ roster looks like:


There’s a reason why this was consistently one of the worst teams in the league. It’s been widely reported that Mexican superstar Erick “Cubo” Torres will not be available in the dispersal draft, and will instead be party to whatever made-up allocation order/birthright/coin-flip deal MLS sees fit.

So, with with Torres unavailable, who should Orlando City target? It’s been my stance that City’s greatest position of need is center back, and veteran defender Bobby Burling might be an appealing choice. I think Andrew Jean-Baptiste and Marco Delgado are promising young players, but with such a young roster already, I can’t imagine Coach Heath will aim to take on more developmental projects.reocoker

If not Burling, Heath could look to shore up the midfield and add Eric Avila, or potentially even English veteran Nigel Reo-Coker. Avila, at only 26, certainly has the potential to be a very useful player for City in the long term. However, a veteran holding midfielder like Reo-Coker could play a major role in keeping a young team organized on the pitch and could influence the development of Harrison Heath.

Aside from the likely unavailable Torres, who off of Chivas’ roster would you most like to see Orlando take?


7 thoughts on “Who Should the Lions Take in Chivas USA Dispersal Draft?”

  1. I agree with all the players you mentioned that Orlando City should target. And I know it all depends on where we draft but I would like to see Kaji in Orlando to give us depth on defense, Prior to acquiring Hall we would have definitely needed Dan Kennedy for our starting GK but since we solidified our starting GK position already Kennedy won’t be a top priority. We can look to add a backup elsewhere since Hall is recovering from injury and hopefully he won’t have to miss any time from games. If for some reason Orlando does get Kennedy he would make for good trade bait.


    1. I’m actually not sure why we didn’t just wait for the dispersal draft and try and grab Kennedy rather than trade allocation money for Hall. Perhaps City has big plans for the International Player Slot they scored in the trade as well.


  2. I think that international slot was a big part of why they did that. And there’s a long way to go before the season. I wouldn’t be surprised if Heath did get Kennedy or another keeper and used him (or Hall) as an asset in a trade to shore up another spot.


  3. Sturgis would be a good pick up. Florida grown, versatile and lots of experience. He may not be a star player, but he would be a good starter or sub. Can play in the back or midfield. Also, Chavez is a good player who can play outside mid or back, but has had some rumors of locker room issues lately. Also, McNamara is young, but showed lots of skill before going down injured in his rookie season.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s